Retiring Senator John Cornyn Uses Blue Slip to Block Texas Judicial Nominee T. Elliott Gaiser

US President Donald Trump’s effort to secure Senate confirmation for as many conservative judges as possible before Democrats take control of the upper chamber suffered a setback on Wednesday when a Republican senator blocked one of his nominees from moving forward.


Retiring Republican Senator John Cornyn of Texas withheld his support for T. Elliott Gaiser, a US Department of Justice official. Gaiser was scheduled to appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, where his nomination for a federal judgeship in Dallas was set to be considered.


By failing to return a "blue slip" a procedural step signaling support Cornyn effectively blocked the nominee. This is the latest instance during the "lame-duck" session the period before Democrats assume control of the Senate on January 3 in which a Republican senator has opposed a White House-backed judicial nominee for a position in their home state.


"He is not from Texas," Cornyn told Reuters. "He has no trial experience, and the White House was trying to foist him upon us for a lifetime appointment without proper vetting."


A White House official stated that they expect all of Trump’s judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year.


Traditionally, senators play a role in selecting candidates to fill federal judicial vacancies within their respective states. Under Senate tradition, senators can effectively veto judicial nominees from their own states by refusing to return a "blue slip" a form used to signal support.


Following the election, Trump nominated 37-year-old Guiser for a seat on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas.


A former Solicitor General of Ohio who previously clerked for conservative U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, he currently heads the Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel a key division that has frequently affirmed the legality of the administration's actions.


During a hearing on Wednesday, Senator Cornyn a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee who had lost a primary challenge to a candidate backed by Trump expressed support for Trump’s decision to nominate Texas Supreme Court Justice James Sullivan for a separate federal judgeship, following Sullivan’s defeat by a Democrat in the recent election.


However, Cornyn has continued to urge the White House to select a different candidate for the seat originally earmarked for Guiser, recommending instead Steve Fahy, a former federal prosecutor in Texas.


"And now, the White House appears to be showing some interest in this proposal," Cornyn said in an interview. Texas Republican Senator Ted Cruz, a supporter of Gaizer, warned in a statement that the White House had indicated it would be "impossible" to complete an FBI background check for an entirely new nominee in time for them to be confirmed.


"If the Senate Judiciary Committee does not move Gaizer forward," Cruz said, "the people of Texas will pay the price, as this would effectively hand the judicial seat over to the Democrats, who would leave it vacant indefinitely."


Two other judicial nominees put forward by Trump also faced similar resistance from Republican senators in their home states following the midterm elections.


On November 10, following opposition from a Republican senator from Arkansas, the White House withdrew the nomination of U.S. District Judge Lee Rudofsky for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, nominating Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland in his place. Hiland appeared alongside six other nominees at a hearing on Wednesday.

Comments